Revision ACL Reconstruction in London

I am Dr Arj Imbuldeniya, a consultant knee surgeon in London. If your ACL reconstruction has failed, the second operation has to do more than replace the graft: it has to find out why the first one failed and put that right.

I operate at The Lister Hospital, Cromwell Hospital and The Clementine Churchill Hospital.

Written and medically reviewed by Dr Arj Imbuldeniya, Consultant Orthopaedic Knee and Hip Surgeon. Last reviewed 17 November 2026. The study behind this page is listed at the end.

Working out why the first graft failed

Before I recommend anything I work out why the first reconstruction failed, because the second operation has to correct the cause and not only replace the graft. The reasons I find most often are tunnels drilled in a position that does not let the graft work properly, muscles that were not strong enough, the build of the knee and leg, and never having been taught how to land safely in sport.

The anatomical factors I look for are a steep slope on the top of the shin bone, known as a high tibial slope, hypermobile joints, a knee that falls inwards (excessive valgus), feet that roll inwards (overpronation) and weak hip abductor muscles.

A first ACL reconstruction needs an MRI scan. For a revision I need both a CT scan and an MRI scan, to assess the bony tunnels, the shape of the bones and the soft tissues.

One operation or two?

This depends mainly on the tunnels drilled in the bone at your first operation, which I assess on the CT scan.

If the old tunnels are in a poor position, I can normally revise the ligament in one operation, because the new tunnels can be drilled through solid bone in the correct place.

If the old tunnels are in a good position, a new tunnel would run straight into them, and if the tunnels have become very wide there is not enough bone to hold a new graft securely. In both situations I mainly do the revision in two stages.

The first stage

At the first operation I remove all of the old graft and fill the tunnels with bone graft, which may be donor bone or your own. I repair any damage to the meniscus or cartilage at the same time and add a lateral extra-articular tenodesis, a reinforcement on the outer side of the knee that helps to control rotation. If the shape of your leg is putting extra load on the ligament, I consider an osteotomy to correct the alignment, and that is normally done at this stage too.

Why I add a lateral extra-articular tenodesis

A lateral extra-articular tenodesis, or LET, uses a strip of the tissue on the outer side of your thigh to help control rotation of the knee. The best evidence for it comes from first-time reconstructions: in the STABILITY trial, 618 patients aged 25 or under at high risk of re-injury had a hamstring graft with or without an LET, and two years later the graft had ruptured in 4% of those with an LET against 11% of those without [1]. That trial did not include revisions, so it is my judgement, not a trial result, that a knee whose first graft has failed benefits from the same extra control.

The wait between stages

The bone graft normally needs three to four months to become part of your own bone before a new tunnel can be drilled through it.

The second stage

At the second operation I reconstruct the ligament with a different graft from the one used the first time. If a hamstring graft was used before, I normally use the quadriceps tendon, although the choice depends on what your previous surgeon used. I tend to use your own tissue for the graft and not donor tendon, and I tend to reinforce the new graft with an internal brace.

If this is your first ACL injury, my page on ACL reconstruction explains the first operation.

Recovery and return to sport

Recovery after the reconstruction is managed in stages.

The first few weeks are about getting the swelling down, getting your full movement back, including a completely straight knee, and waking up the muscles of the leg, which shrink quickly after surgery. Ice matters a great deal, and my knee surgery recovery kit page lists what helps. Keep the dressings dry for the first two weeks to reduce the risk of infection; a waterproof limb cover such as a LimbO makes showering easier. A TENS machine and simple muscle contractions held without moving the joint help the quadriceps in particular, and the hip abductors, adductors, hamstrings and calf need work too. We go very gently on the hamstrings for the first two to four weeks, especially if a hamstring graft was used.

You see me at two weeks. Once the wounds have healed you can start light resistance work in the gym, on an exercise bike and on resistance machines, with your physiotherapist. After four weeks you can push harder with strength training. At three to four months, once your physiotherapist judges the leg strong enough, close to the strength of your other leg, you can start gentle jogging in a straight line on a treadmill. At about six months you can add jump training, then side-to-side and twisting drills, and sport-specific drills such as football or netball by about nine months.

Most people return to sport between nine and 12 months. I prefer 12, to give the graft time to heal into the knee and your muscles time to become as strong as possible, which protects both this knee and the other one.

References

  1. Getgood AMJ, et al. Lateral extra-articular tenodesis reduces failure of hamstring tendon autograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: 2-year outcomes from the STABILITY study randomized clinical trial. Am J Sports Med 2020;48(2):285-97. doi.org/10.1177/0363546519896333

Has your ACL reconstruction failed?

Bring your scans and, if you have it, the operation note from your first surgery. You will leave with an honest answer about why the graft failed and whether your knee needs one operation, two, or none. Consultations with Dr Arj Imbuldeniya are in Mayfair, Kensington, Chiswick and Brentford.

Revision ACL Surgery Cost in London

The cost depends on whether your revision needs one operation or two, and on what has to be done at each. After your consultation my team gives you one written estimate with the exact figure before anything is booked. A new consultation is £350, and every fee I charge is on my pricing page.

Frequently Asked Questions

No. If the old tunnels are in a poor position, the ligament can normally be revised in one operation, because new tunnels can be drilled through solid bone in the correct place. Two stages are mainly needed when the old tunnels are in a good position or have become very wide.

Normally three to four months, which is the time the bone graft in the old tunnels needs to become part of your own bone.

A different graft from the one used at the first operation. If a hamstring graft was used before, I normally use the quadriceps tendon, and I tend to use your own tissue and not donor tendon.

Patient Reviews

What Our Patients Say

Verified Doctify reviews from patients who have received treatment for knee conditions under the care of Dr Arj Imbuldeniya at OrthoLongevity.